Home · Learn · I bonds vs T-bills
Cash · 1–5 year money
Cash you will need in one to five years is not an emergency fund and not a stock index. An I bond is inflation-linked, slow, and capped. A T-bill is a dated Treasury discount that skips state tax. A HYSA is Tuesday money. Google “best cash rate” treats them as flavors of 4%. They are a fork.
Updated 2026-09-08 · 10 min read · Educational, not tax or investment advice. Run the I-bond vs T-bill vs HYSA calculator with your composite, APY, and discount. Defaults are labeled examples, not today’s auction.
| HYSA | T-bill | I bond | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Job | Tuesday money | A known date 4–52 weeks out | Inflation sleeve you can leave 1–5+ years |
| Liquidity | Same day / few days | Hold to maturity or sell | Locked 12 months |
| Early-exit cost | None | Secondary-market price | Last 3 months of interest if cashed before 5 years |
| 2026 size cap | FDIC $250k per depositor per bank | Auction noncompetitive is not a household constraint | $10,000 electronic / SSN / calendar year |
| Federal tax | Ordinary, each year | Ordinary, year of maturity | Ordinary; defer until redemption if you want |
| State / local tax | Yes | No (31 U.S.C. § 3124) | No |
| Rate | Bank can change APY tomorrow | Locked for that bill’s tenor | Fixed rate for 30 years + inflation that resets every 6 months |
People google “I bonds vs HYSA” in a rate-chase mood. The 12-month lock is the whole product. If the money might be rent, a deductible, or a job-loss month, it does not belong in TreasuryDirect.
Worked slice
Example rates, not a live feed: I-bond composite 4.26%, HYSA 4.00% APY, 26-week T-bill 4.10% discount. Federal 22%. I-bond path applies the 3-month penalty (cash at 24 months). After tax: I-bond $10,597, HYSA $10,596, T-bill $10,684. The T-bill wins the 24-month cash race. The I-bond is not a yield bug — it is an inflation sleeve with a lock.
The usual “no”
I-bonds are unredeemable. Accrued value is a museum piece until month 12. HYSA or a T-bill that matures on the date. If your “emergency fund” is in I-bonds, you have a 1-year CD with extra paperwork and a worse Saturday.
| Item | Rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| New-issue composite May–Oct 2026 | 4.26% for the first six months | Fiscal Service, May 1, 2026 |
| Fixed rate in that composite | 0.90% for the 30-year life of that issue | Same release |
| Semiannual inflation piece | 1.67% (CPI-U Sep 2025 → Mar 2026) | Same release |
| Next rate announcement | November 1, 2026 | TreasuryDirect schedule |
| Electronic purchase cap | $10,000 per SSN or EIN per calendar year | 31 CFR 363.52 |
| Minimum electronic purchase | $25, to the penny | TreasuryDirect |
| Redeem | After 12 months | TreasuryDirect I-bond page |
| 3-month penalty | If cashed before 5 years | Same |
| Paper via tax refund | Ended January 1, 2025 | TreasuryDirect / Form 8888 |
Composite formula: fixed + (2 × semiannual inflation) + (fixed × semiannual inflation). Floor at 0% — deflation cannot pull the combined rate negative. The 4.26% figure is the new-issue composite for May 1–October 31, 2026. A bond you bought in 2022 has a different fixed rate and a different current composite. The calculator does not scrape Treasury. You type the rate that applies.
One Social Security number, one calendar year, $10,000 of electronic I bonds. A married couple with two accounts can buy $20,000. A qualifying trust or a real business EIN can buy another $10,000 — Treasury can ignore empty LLCs. Gifts count against the recipient in the year they are delivered.
The extra $5,000 of paper I bonds you used to elect on a tax refund is gone. As of January 1, 2025, I bonds are electronic only. Guides that still mention Form 8888 as a live add-on are stale. If cash is $25,000, the I-bond path is $10,000 in I bonds plus $15,000 in HYSA or T-bills — the calculator splits it that way.
Bills are sold at a discount. Treasury’s price formula is Price = Face × (1 − (discount rate × days) / 360). A 26-week bill uses 182 days. The coupon-equivalent (investment) rate is higher than the discount. The calculator converts discount → period return → a roll over your horizon at the same example rate. Real auctions change every week. Type the high rate from the tenor you will actually buy. Do not paste last month’s headline as if it were a CD.
T-bill interest is the discount, taxed as ordinary federal income in the year the bill matures, even if you immediately roll. State and local income tax: none. That exemption is the product in a 5–13% state. In a 0% state the HYSA vs T-bill fork is mostly liquidity and whether you will actually hold to maturity.
FDIC (or NCUA) coverage, no lock, APY can drop, 1099-INT every year, state tax yes. That is the right wrapper for the 3–12 month sleeve and for sinking funds you might need early. CDs and T-bills can hold dated money (property tax, a closing, tuition). See HYSA vs CDs for the bank-side pair; this page is the Treasury-side pair.
Do not skip a 401(k) match to fill I bonds. A 100% match is not a 4.26% composite. Order of operations still starts at the match — never skip it.
Free tool
User-entered composite / APY / discount, $10k cap, 12-month lock, 3-month penalty, state-tax toggle, bars, shareable URL.
PayPal
12 steps: split the pile, open TreasuryDirect before you need it, cap calendar, ladder the bills, tax lot at redemption.
No. 12-month lock. 3-month penalty before five years. HYSA for Tuesday.
$10,000 electronic per SSN or EIN per calendar year. Paper tax-refund path ended January 1, 2025.
4.26% for May 1–October 31, 2026 issues (0.90% fixed). Type yours. Next print is November 1, 2026.
No. Federal yes, state/local no. HYSA is both. Toggle it in the calculator.
If cashed before five years, you lose the last three months of interest. After five years, none.
Known date, hold to maturity, high state tax. Match tenor to the date. Not rent-due-Friday money.
Yes — $10k per SSN. Gifts count against the recipient when delivered. No more $5k paper add-on.
Federal at redemption (or elect annual). Never state income tax. Education exclusion is Pub. 970, not a slogan.
Educational only. Confirm TreasuryDirect, 31 CFR 363.52, 31 U.S.C. § 3124, and your 1099-INT before you move money. Written by Thomas Sanders.